Skip to Main content

  • Lillo's Tomato Pies

Margherita pizza fresh from a wood-fired oven

lillo’s tomato pies 2503 Marne Hwy

2503 Marne Hwy, Hainesport, NJ
‌
‌
Food
Beverages

Featured Items

  • Original Cheesesteak

    Shaved ribeye & Cooper Sharp. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $13.99

  • Chicken Cutlet

    Hand-breaded chicken cutlet. Choose your cheese and toppings. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $11.99

  • Roast Pork

    Slow-roasted pork, broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, fresh garlic & Pecorino Romano. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $11.99

Food

CHEESESTEAKS

  • Original Cheesesteak

    Shaved ribeye & Cooper Sharp. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $13.99

Chicken Cheesesteak

  • Chicken Cheesesteak

    Chopped chicken on a seeded or plain roll. Choose your cheese (Cooper Sharp, American, provolone, whiz and more) and add toppings like fried onions, hot honey or long hots. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $13.99

Specialty Cheesesteaks

  • Pizza Cheesesteak

    Shaved ribeye, Cooper Sharp & house-made marinara. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $13.99

  • Hot Honey Pepperoni Chicken Cheesesteak

    Fresh chicken breast, Cooper Sharp, cupping pepperoni & hot honey. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $13.99

  • Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

    Fresh chicken breast, Cooper Sharp & buffalo sauce. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $13.99

  • California Cheesesteak

    Shaved ribeye, American cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $13.99

Half Sandwiches with Fries

  • Half Cheesesteak with Fries

    Half of our Original Cheesesteak (shaved ribeye & Cooper Sharp) with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Chicken Cheesesteak with Fries

    Half of our Chicken Cheesesteak with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak with Fries

    Half of our Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak (fresh chicken breast, Cooper Sharp & buffalo sauce) with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Hot Honey Pepperoni Chicken with Fries

    Half of our Hot Honey Pepperoni Chicken Cheesesteak (fresh chicken breast, Cooper Sharp, cupping pepperoni & hot honey) with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Chicken Parm with Fries

    Half of our Chicken Parm (hand-breaded cutlet, house-made marinara & melted mozzarella) with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Chicken Cutlet with Fries

    Half of our hand-breaded Chicken Cutlet sandwich with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Caesar Cutlet with Fries

    Half of our Caesar Cutlet sandwich with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Roast Pork with Fries

    Half of our Roast Pork (slow-roasted pork, broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, fresh garlic & Pecorino Romano) with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

  • Half Plain Steak with Fries

    Half of a plain steak sandwich (shaved ribeye, no cheese) with a side of French fries.
    $15.95

Tomato Pies

New Jersey classic where the cheese goes on the bottom and the crushed tomato sauce is ladled on top. It’s baked to perfection on a thin, crispy crust—light, flavorful, and never floppy. Bold, simple, and iconic.

  • Trenton Tomato Pie

    The Trenton original: a thin, crispy crust with the cheese laid down first and our tomato sauce spread on top, so every bite leads with tomato. Add toppings to the whole pie or just half.
    $19.75

Specialty Pies

  • Nonna Pie

    Marinara base with olive oil, fresh garlic and oregano, topped with fresh wet mozzarella and finished with Pecorino Romano.
    $25.99

  • Mustard Pie

    A Trenton tradition: spicy brown mustard spread right on the crust, then cheese, with our tomato sauce on top. Sharp, savory and unlike any other pizza. Try it with sausage.
    $20.99

  • Pax's Pie

    Hot honey, cupping pepperoni & ricotta.
    $24.99

  • Buffalo Chicken Pie

    Fresh chicken breast, drizzled with hot sauce & ranch.
    $24.99

  • Clams Casino Pie

    A distinctive seafood-inspired pie with rich flavor and a crisp, golden crust.
    $24.99

  • White Pie

    No red sauce here: a cheese base topped with creamy ricotta, broccoli and garlic.
    $21.99

  • Old Fashioned

    $24.99

  • Sicilian

    Our thick, square Sicilian pie, made with Grande mozzarella.
    $20.99

  • Meat Lovers Pie

    Ham, bacon, meatballs, sausage & pepperoni.
    $26.99

  • The Works Pie

    Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers & onions.
    $25.99

  • Vegetarian Pie

    Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives & broccoli.
    $21.99

Slices

  • Plain Cheese Slice

    A classic South Jersey pizza slice with tomato sauce and melted Grande mozzarella.
    $3.75

  • Pepperoni Slice

    A classic slice topped with pepperoni and melted Grande mozzarella.
    $3.99

  • Sausage Slice

    A savory sausage slice with rich flavor and a crisp, golden crust.
    $3.99

  • Mustard Slice

    A distinctive slice with bold mustard flavor and a crisp, golden crust.
    $3.99

  • Nonna Slice

    A signature slice with rich tomato flavor and a crisp, golden crust.
    $3.99

  • White Slice

    A creamy, savory white slice with a golden crust and rich cheese flavor.
    $3.99

  • Buffalo Chicken Slice

    A slice topped with buffalo chicken and a flavorful buffalo finish.
    $3.99

  • Sicilian Slice

    A hearty Sicilian-style slice with a golden crust, rich tomato flavor, and satisfying bite.
    $3.99

  • Old Fashioned Slice

    A classic slice with rich tomato flavor, a crisp crust, and old-school pizzeria appeal.
    $3.99

  • Meat Lover Slice

    A loaded slice for big appetites, packed with classic meat-lover flavor.
    $3.99

  • The Works Slice

    A loaded slice piled with classic toppings for a satisfying, full-flavor bite.
    $3.99

  • Mushroom Slice

    A slice topped with mushrooms.
    $3.99

  • Peppers and Onion Slice

    A savory slice topped with peppers and onions on a crisp, golden crust.
    $3.99

  • Mushroom, Roasted Pepper & Ricotta Slice

    A slice topped with mushrooms, roasted red peppers and ricotta.
    $3.99

Hot Sandwiches

  • Chicken Parm Sandwich

    Hand-breaded chicken cutlet, house-made marinara & melted mozzarella. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $11.99

  • Chicken Cutlet

    Hand-breaded chicken cutlet. Choose your cheese and toppings. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $11.99

  • Roast Pork

    Slow-roasted pork, broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, fresh garlic & Pecorino Romano. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $11.99

  • Meatball Parm Sandwich

    House-made meatballs, house-made marinara & melted mozzarella. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $11.99

  • Caesar Cutlet

    Hand-breaded chicken cutlet with Caesar dressing. Served on your choice of seeded or non-seeded Italian roll, brushed with garlic butter. 6-inch feeds 1-2, 12-inch feeds 3-4.
    $11.99

  • Italian Hot Dog Single

    Trenton-style Italian hot dog, made the way Casino made them: grilled hot dog with fried peppers, onions and potatoes and mustard on a torpedo roll.
    $9.99

  • Italian Hot Dog Double

    Two grilled hot dogs, Trenton Casino-style, with fried peppers, onions and potatoes and mustard on a torpedo roll.
    $14.95

Hoagies

  • Italian Hoagie

    Salami, ham and provolone with lettuce, tomato and onions on a seeded roll.
    $17.95

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    Crisp romaine, Parmesan, and creamy Caesar dressing in a fresh, classic salad.
    $15.95

  • Garden Salad

    A crisp, refreshing salad with fresh vegetables and your choice of dressing.
    $12.95

  • Cheesesteak Salad

    Romaine, cherry tomatoes, shaved ribeye, Cooper Sharp, green peppers & cucumbers.
    $17.95

  • Antipasto Salad

    Romaine, cherry tomatoes, soppressata, capicola, pepperoni, provolone, fresh wet mozzarella, artichokes, croutons & balsamic glaze.
    $17.95

  • Meatball Salad

    Romaine, cherry tomatoes, house-made meatballs, ricotta, Pecorino Romano, house-made marinara & balsamic glaze.
    $15.95

Sides

  • French Fries

    Crispy golden French fries served hot.
    $5.99

  • Cheese Fries

    French fries topped with warm Cheez Whiz.
    $6.99

  • Meatballs (2)

    Two savory meatballs served warm for a satisfying side.
    $5.99

  • Chicken Parm Slider

    A hearty chicken Parm slider with classic Italian-American flavor.
    $7.99

Beverages

  • Can of Soda

    Choose Coke, Diet Coke or Sprite.
    $3.75

  • 2 Litre Soda

    A 2-liter bottle of soda.
    $4.25
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Vegetarian Pie

$21.99

Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives & broccoli.

Customize your item

Additional Toppings

Optional

Pie Modifications

Optional
1

Lillo's Tomato Pies Location and Hours

(609) 491-7751
2503 Marne Hwy, Hainesport, NJ 08036
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 11AM
Facebook logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement