Trenton Tomato Pie Pizza & Cheesesteaks in Hainesport, NJ
Welcome to Lillo's Tomato Pies, the original Lillo's, where authentic Trenton-style tomato pie pizza and garlic-butter cheesesteaks meet family tradition. Founded by Lisa, John, and Lillo Paxia, our family-owned pizzeria brings the cherished flavors of Chambersburg, Trenton to Hainesport, NJ. Dave Portnoy stopped in for a One Bite review and scored our cheesesteak a 9.1 and our tomato pie an 8.4, and we've been featured in The Philadelphia Inquirer and NJ Monthly. Each dish we serve reflects our commitment to quality and our deep-rooted passion for creating memorable dining experiences.
Trenton Tomato Pies
16 oz Steaks
Over 8 unique Sandwiches
Come alone. Come with friends. Come as you are.
Step into a slice of nostalgia at our family-owned pizzeria, where the aroma of fresh-baked pies mingles with the warm sounds of classic tunes. Our cozy dining room buzzes with the familiar chatter of neighbors and friends, creating that authentic old-school pizza shop atmosphere that feels just like home.
From our vintage recipes to our carefully curated playlist of feel-good hits, we've preserved the genuine charm of traditional Italian-American pizzerias while making everyone who walks through our doors feel like part of the family.
Order Direct & Save
Skip the Apps
Ordering right here on our website costs you less than DoorDash or Uber Eats, and every dollar stays with our family-owned shop. Order ahead for quick pickup at 2503 Marne Hwy.
Also in Gloucester City
Our second shop at 157 S Burlington St, Gloucester City has a full bar, every game on TV and a kitchen open until midnight. Call (856) 349-7177.
